Since the Leveson Inquiry started there has been a wholesale change in approach to it by the newspapers and police. Although there are a few gripes, both institutions have ceased attacking the basis of the Inquiry and have settled on a mediation strategy.
Not so the politicians. They are, if anything, incrasingly intransigent in the face of the New World Order and act as if political traps and deceit can still win the day. The Coalition's insistence that Hunt's disreputable behaviour on the BskyB bid should not be subject to Parliamentary scrutiny but deferred until Leveson has taken a view was a desperate attempt to shield him from the inevitable beheading which awaits him. This shows poor judgement by the PM. Again.
To do so would make Brian Leveson the political arbiter in the case and that is a role he will certainly refuse. When Clegg boasted without any basis about bringing forward Hunt's evidence for his political convenience the Inqury said, "Halt."
When Mr Jay, the Leveson Inquiry's QC (pictured) has his opportunity in three weeks time to cross examine Hunt he will no doubt be mindful of the attempt by ministers to push the Inquiry in a particular direction to save Hunt. And the Secretary of State will find political answers will not remotely suffice when posed tough legal questions.
Saturday, 28 April 2012
Wednesday, 25 April 2012
Time to Make Knee Jerk Reactions
When Jeremy Hunt dared to give his statement on his contact with News Corp during the bid process he looked like a man caught 'in flagrante' trying to calm down an irate husband.
He had already spoken at length with Cameron and they had decided between them they should hold the line of denying any wrong doing.
It won't wash. Cameron knows a quick resignation means accepting liability and consolidating the perception of collusion between Ministers and big business. The line Hunt will try to use is that he referred to Ofcom, sought independent advice, PR men will say anything and it was all the fault of my special adviser. It's pretty shakey but could be sustained for a day or two. His suggestion of clearing the air by an early appearance at Leveson is a dreadful strategy. It would mean Cameron suffering three weeks of damaging headlines before Hunt's cross examination.
And when it comes to it I expect a nasty experience in store. Ministers cannot obfuscate, gloss over and interupt in court as easily as at the dispatch box or TV studio. Neil Hamiltion found that in his libel case against the Guardian when George Carmen annihilated him in less than ten minutes.
Rupert Murdoch hits the stand this morning and it may be he has a little more to say on the matter. It would only take one small prod to knock Hunt flying off the political cliff.
He had already spoken at length with Cameron and they had decided between them they should hold the line of denying any wrong doing.
It won't wash. Cameron knows a quick resignation means accepting liability and consolidating the perception of collusion between Ministers and big business. The line Hunt will try to use is that he referred to Ofcom, sought independent advice, PR men will say anything and it was all the fault of my special adviser. It's pretty shakey but could be sustained for a day or two. His suggestion of clearing the air by an early appearance at Leveson is a dreadful strategy. It would mean Cameron suffering three weeks of damaging headlines before Hunt's cross examination.
And when it comes to it I expect a nasty experience in store. Ministers cannot obfuscate, gloss over and interupt in court as easily as at the dispatch box or TV studio. Neil Hamiltion found that in his libel case against the Guardian when George Carmen annihilated him in less than ten minutes.
Rupert Murdoch hits the stand this morning and it may be he has a little more to say on the matter. It would only take one small prod to knock Hunt flying off the political cliff.
Thursday, 19 April 2012
Formula for a Riot
Formula One used to be one of the finest and most exciting sports.
It was a tortuous balance between engineering, driving skill, courage and luck. Drivers such as Graham Hill, Jackie Stewart, Nikki Lauda and Ayrton Senna were suitably celebrrated as great sporting heroes.
But eventually the cars became computerised and the televsion money increased inexorably and sport, for many, simply died. Througout this entire era F1 has ben run by the redoubtable and ruthless Bernie Ecclestone. It is hard to fathom the motivation for an 81 year old who seeks to make even more millions on top of his collosal fortune.
But his bottom line seems to be 'nothing should be allowed to get in the way of commercial gain'. Last year the civil uprising against King Hamad's regime caused the cancellation of the Bahrain Grand Prix but this year it is going ahead. Quite how a sporting event can be staged in the midst of such turmoil and oppression is bizarre. But Bernie who has, on more than one occassion, expressed his admiration for Hitler's organisational skills, has no qualms.
We should remember there have been dozens killed by the security forces, thousand injured and arrested. Medical staff who helped the injured have been imprisoned. Naturally the protestors are channelling their energies to a huge protest aiming to disrupt the race. Meanwhile our Bern says Bahrain is "quiet and peaceful."
All he proves is financial astuteness does not mean he understands the first thing about politics and the value of human rights.
It was a tortuous balance between engineering, driving skill, courage and luck. Drivers such as Graham Hill, Jackie Stewart, Nikki Lauda and Ayrton Senna were suitably celebrrated as great sporting heroes.
But eventually the cars became computerised and the televsion money increased inexorably and sport, for many, simply died. Througout this entire era F1 has ben run by the redoubtable and ruthless Bernie Ecclestone. It is hard to fathom the motivation for an 81 year old who seeks to make even more millions on top of his collosal fortune.
But his bottom line seems to be 'nothing should be allowed to get in the way of commercial gain'. Last year the civil uprising against King Hamad's regime caused the cancellation of the Bahrain Grand Prix but this year it is going ahead. Quite how a sporting event can be staged in the midst of such turmoil and oppression is bizarre. But Bernie who has, on more than one occassion, expressed his admiration for Hitler's organisational skills, has no qualms.
We should remember there have been dozens killed by the security forces, thousand injured and arrested. Medical staff who helped the injured have been imprisoned. Naturally the protestors are channelling their energies to a huge protest aiming to disrupt the race. Meanwhile our Bern says Bahrain is "quiet and peaceful."
All he proves is financial astuteness does not mean he understands the first thing about politics and the value of human rights.
Tuesday, 17 April 2012
The Last Word
Some years ago I worked in a part of the Home Office dealing with the hand-in of firearms after the Dunblane massacre.
I had the occasion to read the Cullen Report which included a passage on what the perpertrator, Thomas Hamilton, had done in detail. It was breathtaking and deeply disturbing, at times impossible to read - it was clear this murderer was exceptional and belonged in Dante's seventh circle of Hell.
The trial of Anders Breivik in Oslo this week has already shown he is even more despicable still. This dim-witted sociopath has no regret whatever about the 77 murderers he committed. He is in effect a modern day SS guard, perhaps he would not even argue with that description. Except many of the loathsome crimes of the SS were driven by the extremes of war. This excrutiating individual has created grand enemies from the safety of his own bedroom, in any case he is intellectually bankrupt and despite his claims of some honour in his 'cause' exists in a moral vacuum.
Sometimes events show there is actual evil within people, very occassionally a person is simply intrinsically evil themselves. It is unfortunate he has the right to publicise his perverse and idiotic beliefs on Norwegian television. I, for one, will not listen or read another word he has to say.
I had the occasion to read the Cullen Report which included a passage on what the perpertrator, Thomas Hamilton, had done in detail. It was breathtaking and deeply disturbing, at times impossible to read - it was clear this murderer was exceptional and belonged in Dante's seventh circle of Hell.
The trial of Anders Breivik in Oslo this week has already shown he is even more despicable still. This dim-witted sociopath has no regret whatever about the 77 murderers he committed. He is in effect a modern day SS guard, perhaps he would not even argue with that description. Except many of the loathsome crimes of the SS were driven by the extremes of war. This excrutiating individual has created grand enemies from the safety of his own bedroom, in any case he is intellectually bankrupt and despite his claims of some honour in his 'cause' exists in a moral vacuum.
Sometimes events show there is actual evil within people, very occassionally a person is simply intrinsically evil themselves. It is unfortunate he has the right to publicise his perverse and idiotic beliefs on Norwegian television. I, for one, will not listen or read another word he has to say.
Monday, 9 April 2012
Not Just Making this Up.
The 'Right to a Family Life' doesn't sound such a bad thing. But in context of immigration law it is an infuriating obstacle to Ministers' ability to deport thousands more foreigners.
The Home Secretary, for it is she, has decided to 'order judges' to ignore Article 8 of the ECHR when deciding on deportation cases. I didn't realise the law worked that way.
I thought laws had to be decided by Parliament or the courts and not in May's little Private Office. Nevertheless the UK is a signatory to ECHR and has also since 2001 brought it into domestic legislation. It cannot be willed away in the desire for favourable headlines in the Sunday Telegraph.
We've been here before of course when she embellished an old social myth about an asylum seeker's cat into the cornerstone of her conference speech.
This is often what happens to Home Secretaries, they lose the ability to listen to officials who might say the latest proposal is pointless, legally unsound and saving up for future embarrassment. They listen to their special advisers who say responds to the real people's expectations, and shows she's gonna act tough. I don't see how this changes anything and judges are not known for being susceptible to taking orders from Ministers.
The Home Secretary, for it is she, has decided to 'order judges' to ignore Article 8 of the ECHR when deciding on deportation cases. I didn't realise the law worked that way.
I thought laws had to be decided by Parliament or the courts and not in May's little Private Office. Nevertheless the UK is a signatory to ECHR and has also since 2001 brought it into domestic legislation. It cannot be willed away in the desire for favourable headlines in the Sunday Telegraph.
We've been here before of course when she embellished an old social myth about an asylum seeker's cat into the cornerstone of her conference speech.
This is often what happens to Home Secretaries, they lose the ability to listen to officials who might say the latest proposal is pointless, legally unsound and saving up for future embarrassment. They listen to their special advisers who say responds to the real people's expectations, and shows she's gonna act tough. I don't see how this changes anything and judges are not known for being susceptible to taking orders from Ministers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)